- Samson Blinded - http://samsonblinded.org/blog -

The cruelty of goodness

Posted By Obadiah Shoher On August 31, 2007 @ 9:54 am In Judea, Samaria, & Gaza | 4 Comments

Residents of the Bronx are ethnically and linguistically similar to the residents of Californian suburbs. They share the same history, goals, and enemies. Even so, no reasonable politician would apply to them similar prescriptions. Yet Israel insists on treating Gaza Strip and the West Bank [1] as a single entity. Such an approach won’t work. Palestine is drifting toward a split into two failed states: Hamas’ Gaza and the pro-Jordanian West Bank.

Egypt is not in the habit of refusing land acquisitions. It confronted Sudan over a minor border dispute, but readily abandoned its right to the Gaza Strip. The place is not worth acquiring if it includes a million Palestinians. Those are the worst Palestinians: fifty-nine years away from their land, refugees living in cramped camps [2] on UN handouts, lacking either employment or any prospect thereof, seething with hate and resentment, claustrophobic as in a prison cell, with no connection to the outside world, accustomed to weapons and violence, they represent the ultimate human waste. That’s not a reason to kill them, but a good reason to abandon them and their territory. Sharon knew the Gazans better than anyone: as a military governor, he managed to keep Gaza quiet with drastic police actions. Sharon had the good sense to disengage from Gaza; he erred only in evicting the Jews rather than the Arabs.

Gaza is overcrowded, unemployed, humiliated, and drastically different from the relatively peaceful and affluent West Bank. Gazans have been driven to the edge. Unemployed Gazans breed huge families on international welfare. Jews have severely restricted their movement to the West Bank and their labor migration to Israel. The desperate Arab population supports radicals and breeds suicide bombers. Young Arabs with no life opportunities, with no money to marry, readily die for high ideals. Gaza, once a notoriously irreligious place, is quickly becoming a hotbed of Islam. Palestinians, unable to achieve anything in this life, look for otherworldly goals. They see no benefit in living, and aren’t afraid of dying; they take suicide missions matter-of-factly. Israel and the UN let the steam out of Gaza with humanitarian aid, prolonging the suffering. Either push them to an explosion, or let them live—which they cannot do if Gaza remains isolated. Israel pushes Gazans to the wall and offers them no hope of relief except through terrorism. Not surprisingly, Palestinian terrorists have killed more Jews in the six years since Oslo then in a similar period of Intifada before Oslo. Jewish casualties in terrorist attacks exceed the 7,268 lost in the Yom Kippur war. Militant groups fight Israel as the only way to curry support among Palestinians. Neither Hamas nor the PIJ can better the Palestinians’ lives, and fighting Israel is their only electoral platform.

Very few Palestinians engage in terrorism, and many others rat on them to Israeli security services, but those few are enough to perpetuate terrorism; and other Palestinians who quietly hate Israel support them. Palestinians, weary of war and hardship, might elect moderates, but the brewing discontent would continue churning out suicide bombers. Palestinians actually did vote for moderation—but not for moderates, because none are available. In the conundrum of hatred and discontent, terrorism and retaliation, unemployment and propaganda, moderate parties cannot arise; it took the devastation of WWII and years of stability for moderate parties to appear in Germany. Only 4 percent of Palestinians voted for the PFLP, which is strictly a guerrilla group with no immediate political agenda. Pre-election polls indicated that Hamas’ 44 percent electoral support included about 15 percent undecided; only a third of Palestinians supported Hamas in the months before the elections. A drop of public support for Hamas during its clashes with Fatah shows that many Palestinians voted for Hamas as a decent Islamic charity and anti-corruption organization rather than a guerrilla group. Of the 41percent of Palestinians who voted for Fatah, some imagined that Abbas would bring peace with Israel while others simply voted for the current ruling party; 15-20 percent of any population always votes for the governing party. The most telling thing about the 2006 Palestinian elections was a 75 percent voter turnout in Gaza. Such a turnout is high for most countries, but note that Gazans are largely unemployed; elections are a form of entertainment for them. That a quarter of Gazans abstained from voting shows their deep frustration with all political parties. The Arabs of Gaza hate Israel and would love to see her destroyed and themselves returned to their old villages. They cheer attacks on Israel, but prefer a minimally safe life for themselves. They enjoy Hamas’ struggle with Israel, but hate to suffer Israel’s retaliation. Gaza’s Palestinians would love to live in peace and affluence. In practice, that’s not possible. Gaza is just not a viable territory.

Israelis are used to primitive moralizing, which presumes that one side is right and the other wrong. Jews therefore consistently picture the Palestinians as hateful terrorist scum with no right to the land. But try visiting Palestinian refugee camps. Their residents dream of Palestine so vividly that their dreams are hardly distinguishable from reality. They talk of their grandparents’ villages, which they have never seen, but which exist in their dreams. They talk of the number of olives trees and sheep they had. They are ready to fight and die for the land—and kill, too. They are honest, determined people made to live unbearable lives. The Jews need this land, and have to expel the Arabs to make a Jewish state. That’s a fact of life. But the other side has a strong moral position.

Israel made a zoo out of Gaza; she gives Palestinians water and food, but keeps the place closed. The most prominent feature of a zoo is the overwhelming disparity between guards and animals. When Arabs bark with homemade Kassams, Israelis fly in on fighter jets and attack helicopters and punish the Palestinians with precision rocket fire. Animals in the zoo have to accept their lot, but become angrier day by day.

The zoo is profitable for its keepers on both sides. Abu Mazen’s son owns six companies in Israel. Barak gave Arafat a gas field to lease to British Gas for kickbacks. Israel’s secret police officer Yossi Ginossar handled Arafat’s accounts in Israel. Shin-Bet officers [3] do business with Palestine. Israeli oligarchs have monopolized the commodity trade with Palestine. The IDF declared that the invasion of Gaza poses no threat to the kidnapped Cpl. Shalit, even though he is held by extreme Palestinian militants; such certainty reveals an astonishing degree of cooperation between Israeli security services and Palestinian terrorists. The Shin-Bet security service catches almost all suicide bombers, even though the guerrilla operations are highly secret; officials in the terrorist groups betray their suicide bombers to Israel in return for large rewards. Terrorist groups refrain from attacking Israel’s soft underbelly—foreign Jews and Israelis abroad—in return for Shin Bet’s tacit agreement not to arrest top terrorist officials.

Palestine was quiet until Shimon Peres brought the PLO from Tunis. Israel supported the PLO against Hamas, and later supported Hamas to contain the PLO. Hamas predictably won, ascending in a political tide too strong to control militarily. Palestinians want an honest government which, in that context, could only be Islamic—atheist Palestinian leaders see no reason to abstain from corruption.

Stop oppressing the Palestinians. A frightened skunk doesn’t smell good. Kick him out of our backyard.


Article printed from Samson Blinded: http://samsonblinded.org/blog

URL to article: http://samsonblinded.org/blog/the-cruelty-of-goodness.htm

URLs in this post:

[1] Gaza Strip and the West Bank: http://samsonblinded.org/blog/end-gaza.htm

[2] refugees living in cramped camps: http://samsonblinded.org/blog/unrwa-a-sponsor-of-terrorism.htm

[3] Shin-Bet officers: http://samsonblinded.org/blogsamsonblinded.org/news/shin-bet-hamas-prepares-for-israeli-invasion-505