I learned of the Dahab bombing with mixed feelings. I cannot honestly say I am too sorry for the eighteen dead Egyptians or the few foreigners. Rather, I was glad that my prognosis was correct: I pointed to Dahab as the next target after Taba and Sharm esh-Sheikh, and specifically on Easter. Indeed, I dissuaded a couple of friends from going to Dahab this Easter. The date was pretty obvious: a joint holiday for Egyptian Muslims and Christians and end of the Jewish holidays. The target was clear, too: terrorists had to pick a new town to avoid being labeled a local phenomenon, and picked Dahab over even more jerkwater Nuweiba. What seems really odd to me is, why Sinai? Hurghada and the nearby tourist villages offer much more simple logistics if the perpetrators are the usual suspects, South Egyptian followers of Al Banna. A new Lavon affair being an option, a much more plausible explanation is that we are dealing with a highly distributed insurrection. And yes, Egypt is burning. I hate listening to the peace pitches of my colleagues who have never dealt with Arab mobs. I do. In fact, I recently spent two weeks in Egypt—not at receptions but with common Egyptians.
I rode buses and dime-a-trip minivans, stayed in $3-a-night hotels, and ate fuul in fly-blown eateries. I was shocked. I hadn’t been to Egypt for almost a year, and the change was tremendous. People are no longer afraid of the government. They sense that Hosni will pass away soon, and that any successor will be weak, possibly even a democratic weakling.
Among dozens of people I spoke to, not a single one hesitated to approve of Muslim Brotherhood. That startlingly contrasted the situation a year ago, when many Egyptians disapproved of the group, and many were afraid to approve publicly. Quite a few people now ventured more than tacit approval once prompted. Everyone supported the attacks in Taba and Sharm esh-Sheikh. As usual, most viewed terrorists as Robin Hoods who sabotage hated government and corrupt police. But I also saw an increase in anti-Israeli feelings. Egyptians, as everyone, do not care about Palestinians, but unlike most others, the Egyptians do not pretend they care. They want revenge. Restitution of Sinai left Israel without bargaining chips, and proved insufficient to expiate the offense of prevailing against Egypt. There is much talk of revenge around the corner.
Egyptians know they cannot dominate Middle East if Israel exists. They, like other Arabs, became increasingly nationalist, and want to dominate. Expunging Israel from the region is on the mob’s lips. I saw dramatic increase in Muslim observance among middle class. Several friends who wrank alcohol with me before now seriously spoke of Koran’s infallibility. True, they despise the radicals, but only because radicals threaten stability which the middle class values. Many revolutions showed that the middle class opposition is neither stable nor strong: professionals join radicals or fall prey to them. Many politicians and professors who belong to Muslim Brotherhood or favor them, are ostensibly moderate. Such was the case in all revolutions: moderate intellectuals and passionate activists. Passion has always won; intellect was subverted and subdued.
Egyptian government is desperate. There is more police than usual on every corner: pathetically underpaid, proverbially corrupt, and breathtakingly inept. Automatic rifles are useless in crowded markets and bus stations, checkpoints do not stop bomb traffickers, and security convoys are counterproductive when ambushed. In South Egypt, my taxi driver joined a police-protected convoy, three-mile long line of vehicles. Then, at the middle of the road, the convoy stopped for coffee break. And it does so daily, in the same place. Wanna ambush it?
Post-Dahab measures amounted to laughable show of force: paramilitary troops running around with shields and wooden sticks. The government could do nothing about terrorism. And Muslim Brotherhood already controls the largest faction in parliament. The government recently fired two judges who criticized rigged elections. More to come. Minimally transparent elections will make Muslim Brotherhood parliamentary majority. They have impeccable credentials: they are the only ones who are not corrupt. And they are sufficiently strong - as terrorist acts show - if not to end the corruption, then at least to punish the practitioners awesomely. Muslim Brotherhood will not deliver prosperity, as the ayatollahs did not, but economic problems will become prominent only later. Just as the ayatollahs, Muslim Brotherhood will radicalize foreign politics to divert attention from their mishandling of economy. Unlike with the ayatollahs, the West will accommodate Muslim Brotherhood: you don’t ostracize nuclear imams, lest they go test the promise of seventy virgins.
Egypt is burning. And it will fall to the radicals. We will have a nuclear neighbor state which deals in jihad, sharia, and glorious afterlife, not mutually assured destruction. Islamic nuclear axis will extend to the border of Israel. We could defuse the threat years ago with draconian military measures, massive propaganda, and elimination of the Egyptian nuclear capabilities. Now it’s just too late. The bombs which will detonate in New York and Tel Aviv are being built. The people who will give orders to deliver them are ascending to power. And we are waiting for it.


Hello from Italy! Your blog is fantastic! Please, if you have just a free minute, visit me back and leave a comment with your link, so other Italian people will be able to visit you! Thank you!;-DCavmi
You wrote : I cannot honestly say that I am too sorry for the 18 Egyptians dead there, or for a few foreigners…
Who are you Obadiah Shoher … and who give you the rights to write in such a disrespect for human life ?
I live since 7 years in Dahab and i lost last april a friend …
in 4 weeks it's anniversary …
Obadiah differentiates between the respect for human life and compassion. Respect means not taking it in vain. Compassion means caring if others do so.
YOU JUST APPROVED YOUR DISRESPECT TO THOSE WHO DIED, WHAT DO YOU THINK PEOPLE WILL SAY AFTER YOU DIE. WHO TOLD YOU THE THE EGYPTIAN DO NOT CARE FOR THE PALESTINIANS AND YOU SHOULD ASCERTAIN YOU RESOURCES SINCE THE TWO JUDGES YOU SPOKE ABOUT ARE NOT FIRED. I UNDERSTAND IT IS YOUR RIGHT TO EXPRESS YOUR OPINION,BUT YOU SHOULD BE HONEST WHEN SPEAKING ABOUT THOSE THAT YOU JUST JUST VISIT EVERY YEAR OR WHATEVER.
Just sorry for your confussion. Did you was running against a door while before writing :
"I cannot honestly say that I am too sorry …"
Come down from your philosophic talking and think what you would tell a victim mother 'face to face'. Maybe you are to proud to do.. than sorry for you, really.
I don't envisage any problem talking to a mother of some Muslim killed by Muslim terrorists. A clear case of clinical detachment.
You said :
massive propaganda, and elimination of the Egyptian nuclear capabilities. Now it’s just too late. The bombs which will detonate in New York and Tel Aviv are being built.
1)Egypt has no nuclear power even for peace purposes.
2)Again you try to put Tel Aviv and New York in one place to give an impression to people that u both are the victim of terrorists and to gain sympathy of the american public…the same dirty game is played every time.
3)Many people in Egypt would like to select the Muslim brotherhood…because they r being dealt with in an unfair way….and those who has tasted injustice are the best to be fair when they rule…and however…many Egyptians would select them .. not the great majority as u want to say.
4)when you die bombed and your body come into pieces…nobody will feel sorry for you also…and may be you get killed by your own terrorists who killed Rabin before.
5)you claim that Egyptian people dosn't care about Paletinians….this is very wrong because in Islamic relegion…the blood of a single Muslim victim (whom you slaughter everyday) are even more precious than MAKKA.
6)you are like a fire…when it dosn't find something to eat…it just eats itself.
French plutonium extraction module at Inchass?
2005 IAEA scandal over undisclosed work with uranium?
Gamal Mubarak confirmed the Egyptian nuclear program in September 2006?
It've just spent an hour reading your blog for the first time, here are my impressions:
)
- Your writting style is really nice, dynamic and affirmed.
- I disagree with you on several fundamental ideas, but that is one's independent opinion and I respect it as such.
- But unfortunately many important statements of yours are just completely incorrect, and I am disappointed that such a well-known israeli blog on foreign policy does not feature interesting source-based analysis but rather man-in-the-street prejudices.
I still can't believe how ignorant of each other Egyptians and Israelis are…Trust me you barely know Egypt, but you dare write about it as if "you knew", no you don't.
The great majority of Egyptians rejected the Dahab attacks against Israeli tourists. You'd be surprised if you talked on a daily basis with Egyptians, to hear their real feelings and aspirations vis-a-vis Jews and Israel. They're not monsters, very far from that. It's just that you don't even speak their language, and what do you expect anyway from these unsignificant trips?? Be modest, learn and discover, then maybe you could get back to this blog after a while (2030??
Keep it real..
shalom/salam
Well, James, I bet you are talking with mid-class inhabitants of Cairo. Venture ten miles into the development communities outside Cairo for a different view.
Also, the mid-class Egyptians, just like the mid-class Germans in late 1930s, despise disorganized violence rather than killing of Jews per se.
Oh I'm sorry loving foreigners. I know that you cry in your beds like babies every time a Jew is murdered, and go insane with grief every time a bomb goes in an Israeli city, or some Arab guns down a few teenagers in a mall,
Because you care so much about the life of all living creatures, including Israelis.
So a couple of us too show how much we care about your life, and shrug with indifference whenever some of you get blown up.
And, because you like coming up with excuses for your hatred of Jews, I can come up with one too:
The killings are only a fitting retaliation for all the years that muslims were opressed and mistreated under colonial and imperial rule, and for all the crimes that the Byzantines have performed against the Saracens.